1. Christmas Eve In My Hometown - Scott Ellis & Susan Stroman, written by Stan Zabka & Don Upton
2. Deck The Halls - Robert Morse, Welsh carol
3. Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow! - Cheryl Bentyne, words by Sammy Cahn, music by Jule Styne
4. Fast Falls The Snow - Mary D'Arcy & Mark Jacoby, words by Mortimer Collins, music by Polly Pen
5. I Wonder As I Wander - Maureen McGovern, Appalachian carol
6. The Christmas Song/A Crazy Christmas List - Brian Stokes Mitchell, The Christmas Song: Mel Torme & Robert Wells, A Crazy Christmas List: Brian Stokes Mitchell
7. What Makes Santa Run? - Ervin Drake, written by Ervin Drake
8. It's Beginning To Look Like Christmas - Scott Bakula, written by Meredith Willson
9. I'm Gonna Be An Angel - John Kander & Fred Ebb, words by Fred Ebb, music by John Kander
10. Three Wishes For Christmas - Carolyn Mignini, words by Stephen Sondheim, music by Jule Styne
11. One Family - Richard Kiley, Dierdre Kiley, Sheldon Harnick, Margery Harnick, words by Sheldon Harnick, music by Michel Legrand
12. For You - Michele Brourman, words by Janis Cercone, music by Michele Brourman
13. Mele Kalikimaka - The Cast of Forever Plaid, written by Alex Anderson
14. Winter Wonderland - The Cast of Forever Plaid, words by Dick Smith, music by Felix Bernard
15. I'll Be Home For Christmas - Karen Ziemba, written by Buck Ram, Walter Kent & Kim Gannon
16. O Holy Night - Holly Near & Brian Green, words by J.S. Dwight, music by Adolphe Adam, new lyrics by Holly Near
17. Once Upon A Christmas Time - Nikki Rene, words by David Cady, music by Steve Marzullo
18. Jingle Bells - BETTY, written by J. Pierpont
19. Surabaya Santa - Kristine Zbornik, written by Jason Robert Brown & Kristine Zbornik
20. All I Want For Christmas Is You - Amanda McBroom & George Ball, words by Amanda McBroom, music by Tom Snow
21. Star Of Wonder - The Arlettes, written by Terre Roche
22. O Little Town Of Bethlehem - Melba Moore, words by Phillips Brooks, music by Lewis H. Redner
23. Silent Night - D.C. Anderson, Claudia Anderson & Jim J. Bullock, words by Joseph Mohr, music by Franz GrŸber
24. Santa Took The Subway - Anthony Crivello, written by Anthony Crivello
25. Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer - David Staller, written by Johnny Marks, additional dialogue by David Staller
26. The Perfect Christmas Eve - Roslyn Kind, written by Dale Gonyea
27. Merry Christmas, Darling - Davis Gaines, written by Frank Pooler & Richard Carpenter
28. Do Your Christmas Lovin' Early - Portia Nelson & William Roy, written by Portia Nelson
29. My Christmas Song For You - Andrea Marcovicci, words by Furniss Peterson & Paul Francis Webster, music by Hoagy Carmichael
30. Christmas In New York - Leslie Uggams, written by Ervin Drake
31. Christmas In Beverly Hills - Dale Gonyea, written by Dale Gonyea
32. It's Christmas And We're Jewish - Karen Benjamin & Alan Chapman, written by Alan Chapman
33. Some Children See Him - Howard McGillin, words by Wihla Hutson, music by Alfred Burt
34. What Child Is This? - Jeff Harnar, Traditional
35. Dawn Carol - Wayne Moore and Brenda Silas Moore, words by Doris Moore, music by Wayne Moore
36. Christmas Feels Just Like Love - Babbie Green, words and music by Babbie Green
37. All Those Christmas Cliches - Lainie Kazan, words by Lynn Ahrens, music by Stephen Flaherty
38. A Tuna Story - Jaston Williams, written by Jaston Williams
39. Don't Let Gramma Cook Christmas Dinner - Roy Zimmerman, written by Roy Zimmerman
40. Remember/Toyland - K.T. Sullivan, Remember: written by Harry Nilsson, Toyland: words by Glen MacDonough, music by Victor Herbert
41. Wishing You A Drag Queen Christmas - B.D. Wong, words by Bill Russell, music by Janet Hood
42. The Truth About Christmas - Alix Korey, written by David Friedman
43. It Came Upon A Midnight Clear - Karen Akers, written by Edmund Sears & Richard H. Willis
44. Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas - Tommy Tune, words by Hugh Martin, music by Ralph Blane
45. Christmas On Broadway - Karen Culliver & Betty Garrett, written by Alan Chapman
