1. Are You Burning, Little Candle (3:47) by Jane Siberry; arr: Rick Snyder; piano: Steven Landau
2. Three Wishes for Christmas (1:39) words by Stephen Sondheim, music by Jule Styne; piano: Lem Jay Ignacio
3. Christmas Island at Christmas Time (1:40) lyrics by Stephen Sondheim, music by Mary Rodgers; bass: Ritt Henn
4. Silent Night (3:28) lyrics by Joseph Mohr, music by Franz Gruber; add'l vocals: Claudia Anderson, Jim J. Bullock; guitar and arr. by Roy Zimmerman; oboe: Kathy Robinson; previously released on Cabaret Noël: A Broadway Cares Christmas; used by permission.
5. Infant Holy (1:23) Polish carol arranged by Craig S. Kingsbury
6. Winter, Fire and Snow (1:00) by Brendan Graham and MacDara Woods
7. When a Child is Born (1:40) by Roy Zimmerman; piano: Lem Jay Ignacio
8. Dickens Carolers (2:34) lyrics and arr. by Richard Gray; add'l vocalists Wren Harrington, Steven Landau, Melody Rubie
9. A Marshmallow World (2:11) lyrics by Carl Sigman, music by Peter De Rose; piano: Lem Jay Ignacio
10. Up on a Mayberry Housetop (0:56) medley: Up on the Housetop by Benjamin Russell Hanby; The Fishin' Hole by Everett Sloane, Earle Hagen, and Herbert Spencer; Arr. by Steve Landau; bass: Ritt Henn; whistlists: D.C. and Ritt.
11. I'm Gonna Be an Angel (2:11) lyrics by Fred Ebb, music by John Kander; piano: Steven Landau
12. Hands (3:52) lyrics by D.C. Anderson, music by Steven Landau; piano: Steven Landau
13. The Rest of the Year (2:36) by David Buskin; piano: Lem Jay Ignacio
14. The UPS Bell Carol (1:34) lyrics and arr. by Richard Gray; (Carol of the Bells by Leontovich) additional vocals by Wren Marie Harrington, Steven Landau, Melody Rubie
15. Department Stores Mean Christmas to Me (2:54) words by D.C. Anderson, music by Steve Landau; piano: Lem Jay Ignacio
16. Heaven Can't Be Far (3:23) lyrics by Susan Birkenhead, music by Lucy Simon; guitar: Steve Bargonetti
17. O Joyful Children (2:13) lyrics by Mary Pjerrou Huckaby, music by Lee Holdridge; piano: Lem Jay Ignacio